A Practical Buyer’s Guide
How to Choose an Energy Consulting Firm for a Multi-Location Business
The right energy partner should do more than identify potential savings. It should understand how your locations operate, help your team act on the information, and verify whether the expected results were achieved.
This guide explains what multi-site restaurant, retail, and franchise organizations should evaluate before selecting an energy consulting firm.
Review the Evaluation CriteriaStart With the Need
Define What You Actually Need the Firm to Manage
“Energy consulting” can describe very different services. Before comparing companies, determine which responsibilities need to be covered.
One-Time Analysis
A focused audit, benchmarking study, project review, or utility-rate analysis with defined recommendations and deliverables.
Project Implementation
Controls, lighting, metering, equipment upgrades, rebates, or other capital projects that require design and coordination.
Ongoing Management
Continuous monitoring, reporting, procurement, controls support, issue identification, and follow-up across multiple locations.
A firm that is well suited for a one-time engineering study may not be equipped to monitor hundreds of locations. Likewise, a software platform may organize data effectively but provide limited operational guidance.
Evaluation Criteria
What to Look for in an Energy Consulting Firm
Relevant Multi-Site Experience
Look for experience with organizations that operate many similar locations. Multi-site programs require consistent processes, portfolio comparisons, scalable reporting, and coordination with different managers, utilities, vendors, and markets.
Industry and Equipment Knowledge
The firm should understand how HVAC, lighting, refrigeration, controls, operating schedules, and occupancy affect your specific type of facility. A restaurant, retail store, warehouse, and hospital do not use energy in the same way.
Utility Data Capabilities
Confirm how the firm collects, validates, normalizes, and analyzes utility data. Ask how it handles missing bills, estimated readings, new locations, closures, weather, rate changes, and data errors.
Operational Follow-Through
Recommendations have limited value if no one acts on them. Determine who investigates issues, communicates with your team, follows up with contractors, and verifies that corrective work was completed.
Savings Verification
Ask how projected and actual savings will be calculated. The method should account for weather, changes in operating hours, store openings and closures, equipment changes, and other material factors.
Technology and Data Access
Understand which systems will be used, who owns the data, whether information can be exported, and what happens if the relationship ends. Avoid unnecessary dependence on a closed platform.
Geographic Coverage
A multi-state organization may need knowledge of different utilities, energy markets, codes, incentive programs, climate zones, labor markets, and contractor networks.
References and Documented Results
Ask for relevant examples involving comparable facilities, location counts, and operating conditions. A percentage savings claim without a baseline, time period, and methodology provides limited evidence.
Business Model
Understand How the Firm Is Paid
Compensation affects incentives. There is nothing inherently wrong with commissions, project margins, subscriptions, or shared savings, but the structure should be clear before recommendations are accepted.
| Compensation Model | Potential Advantage | Question to Ask |
|---|---|---|
| Fixed consulting fee | Defined scope and predictable cost | What work or follow-up is outside the fee? |
| Monthly subscription | Supports ongoing monitoring and management | What work is performed each month? |
| Supplier commission | Can reduce or eliminate direct procurement fees | Which suppliers pay the firm, and how is the commission calculated? |
| Equipment or project margin | Combines design, equipment, and implementation | Are competing options considered when no sale is involved? |
| Shared savings | Connects compensation to measured performance | How is the baseline established and adjusted? |
Ask the firm to disclose material commissions, referral fees, equipment margins, and other financial relationships that could influence a recommendation.
Technology
Protect Access to Your Systems and Data
Technology can improve a multi-site energy program, but it can also create unnecessary dependence. Before choosing a platform or consulting partner, clarify the following:
- Your organization can export its utility and equipment data
- Ownership of collected and calculated data is clearly defined
- APIs or standard export formats are available when needed
- The system can integrate with existing controls and software
- User access is not limited to the consulting firm
- Cybersecurity and access responsibilities are documented
- Historical data remains available if the relationship ends
- Subscription and support costs are disclosed before implementation
Savings Claims
Require a Clear Method for Measuring Results
A credible firm should be willing to explain both what created the savings and how the calculation was performed.
Baseline
Which historical period will be used, and were the bills complete and representative of normal operation?
Adjustments
How will weather, operating hours, remodels, new equipment, pricing, openings, closures, and other changes be treated?
Persistence
Will performance be checked after implementation to confirm that schedules, controls, and operating practices remain effective?
Warning Signs
Red Flags When Evaluating a Firm
- Guaranteed savings before reviewing actual data
- Large percentage claims without a defined baseline
- Recommendations limited to products the firm sells
- Unclear commissions, referral fees, or equipment margins
- No relevant multi-site client references
- Limited access to your own data or systems
- Long contracts without clear deliverables or exit terms
- Reports that identify problems but provide no follow-up process
- Proprietary calculations that cannot be explained
- No distinction between energy savings and cost savings
Selection Meeting
Questions to Ask Before Hiring an Energy Consulting Firm
- How many multi-location restaurant, retail, or franchise organizations do you currently support?
- Which services are performed by your employees and which are subcontracted?
- How do you collect, validate, and normalize utility data?
- How will you identify and communicate problems that require action?
- Who is responsible for follow-up after an issue is identified?
- How do you calculate projected and actual savings?
- What commissions, referral fees, or equipment margins may apply?
- Who owns the data, and can we export it in a usable format?
- What systems, subscriptions, and ongoing fees will be required?
- What happens to our data and system access if the agreement ends?
- Can you provide references from organizations with similar locations and operating conditions?
- What specific work and deliverables are included in the proposed fee?
Decision Framework
A Simple Evaluation Scorecard
Score each firm using the same criteria. Adjust the weighting based on the work you actually need rather than giving every category equal value.
| Category | Suggested Weight | What to Evaluate |
|---|---|---|
| Relevant experience | 20% | Industry, location count, facility type, and geographic reach |
| Technical capabilities | 20% | Utility analysis, controls, equipment, procurement, and measurement |
| Implementation and follow-up | 20% | Issue ownership, communication, project management, and verification |
| Technology and data access | 15% | Integration, exports, APIs, ownership, cybersecurity, and portability |
| Commercial terms | 15% | Fees, commissions, margins, contract term, and exit provisions |
| References and results | 10% | Comparable clients, documented outcomes, and measurement methods |
Frequently Asked Questions
Choosing an Energy Consulting Partner
What does an energy consulting firm do?
Services vary. An energy consulting firm may analyze utility data, identify efficiency opportunities, evaluate rates, manage procurement, develop projects, implement controls, support rebates, monitor performance, or provide ongoing energy-management services.
Should we hire a consultant or build an internal energy team?
The answer depends on the size and complexity of the portfolio. A large organization with established controls, procurement, engineering, and data teams may benefit from internal ownership. Smaller and mid-sized multi-location organizations may gain broader expertise at a lower fixed cost through an outsourced partner.
How should an energy consultant calculate savings?
The firm should use a defined baseline and explain adjustments for weather, operating hours, rate changes, new equipment, remodels, openings, closures, and other material changes. The calculation should distinguish reductions in energy use from reductions in utility cost.
Is it a conflict if the firm receives supplier commissions?
Not automatically. Commission-based compensation is common in energy procurement. The important issues are disclosure, supplier access, contract transparency, and whether the compensation could affect the recommendation.
Who should own the energy and utility data?
The client should retain practical access to its source data and historical records. Contract terms should explain ownership, export options, system access, retention, and what happens when the relationship ends.
What is the biggest warning sign when selecting a firm?
Be cautious when a firm promises specific savings before reviewing actual utility data, operating conditions, equipment, and existing energy-management practices.
Need Help Evaluating Your Current Energy Program?
GWT2Energy works with multi-site restaurant and retail organizations to evaluate utility performance, controls, procurement, equipment operation, and ongoing energy-management needs.
Schedule a Call